Sunday, September 16th, 2007 11:17 pm
vid rec - this woman's work by holly gilmore
This Woman's Work by Holly Gilmore, Firefly, Zoe, Zoe/Wash.
Hmm. I was going to do this as a conditional, but I changed my mind. There's some odd clip order choices, but to be honest, first, second, and third watch, I just didn't care. It's powerful and it made me cry. Spoilers through the movie.
Not being a great critiquer of vidding, I only really know what I like and what didn't work. There were bits I think would have been better in different places, and I think that using the movie as a frame for it all would have worked a lot better instead of doing most of that at the beginning.
But. It's so powerful, and it's moving, and it got across emotion pitch-perfect. Adding to favorites.
ETA: Corrected vidder's name (thanks,
thefourthvine!)
Hmm. I was going to do this as a conditional, but I changed my mind. There's some odd clip order choices, but to be honest, first, second, and third watch, I just didn't care. It's powerful and it made me cry. Spoilers through the movie.
Not being a great critiquer of vidding, I only really know what I like and what didn't work. There were bits I think would have been better in different places, and I think that using the movie as a frame for it all would have worked a lot better instead of doing most of that at the beginning.
But. It's so powerful, and it's moving, and it got across emotion pitch-perfect. Adding to favorites.
ETA: Corrected vidder's name (thanks,
no subject
From:(- reply to this
- parent
- top thread
- link
)